← Back to All Articles
The 4 Types of People to Check In With on a Regular Basis

The 4 Types of People to Check In With on a Regular Basis

Four kinds of church members every pastor should check in with often: the sage, the well-connected, the wallflower, and the first-time visitor.

By Thomas Griffin, Owner and CEO

Published · Updated

A pastor should check in often with four kinds of people who are easy to miss. The sage is your longest-serving member. The well-connected person knows everyone. The wallflower serves quietly in the background. And the visitor is new to the church. Each one gives the church something, and each one needs to hear from you.

In pastoral care, you check in with a lot of people all the time. Every check-in matters, but a few people need special thought. They are not more important than anyone else. But these four types can help the care ministry in unique ways. Maybe you have not noticed them yet, but you already know them. When we describe them, you will know exactly who we mean. For each one, we will cover what they need, what they offer, and how to connect.

Who Should a Pastor Check In With? A Quick Guide

PersonWhy they need youWhat they giveHow to connect
The sageThey can be taken for granted.Wisdom and the church's story.A visit or call. Ask for their story.
The well-connectedThey want more ways to serve.Context on people and a gift for welcome.Pick up the phone. Bring them along.
The wallflowerTheir work often goes unseen.Careful listening and sharp insight.A quiet word or a thank-you note.
The visitorBeing new is hard.Fresh eyes, new gifts, and new friends.A warm note within the week, then a next step.

The Sage

Who they are: Not always the oldest person, but your oldest member. This person has been part of the church for a long time and has watched its story unfold over years, sometimes over a whole lifetime. Their roots run deep. They know the life of the church well and care about its future.

Why they need to hear from you: Because they are so much a part of church life, these members are easy to take for granted. Let them know they are not forgotten and how much they are valued. Their faithfulness deserves to be named out loud.

Why you need to hear from them: Long-time members have been through many milestones with the church family beside them. They can tell you what helped most in those seasons. They also know the story of your congregation. Their insight can help the members who come behind them.

How to connect: Visit or call them personally. Invite them to share guidance and perspective that can help the whole church. You might also find ways to preserve their stories and honor their journey with the church. If they can no longer get to services, a regular visit or call matters even more. Our homebound ministry guide can help you plan those visits.

The Well-Connected

Who they are: You know them. Everyone knows them. These members are social, warm, and gifted with people. Need we say more? You likely already have a few names in mind.

Why they need to hear from you: This member is very engaged and likely wants more ways to connect and serve. They might even be on the care team already.

Why you should touch base: This member can be a great help to the care team. They often know what is going on in people's lives. They know how to make new people feel welcome. And they may have an eye for spotting someone's gifts. A care team can use these skills to help the church grow closer.

How to connect: Just pick up the phone! They will be glad you thought of them. They will also enjoy going to community events with you, helping with a project, or sitting down for coffee so you can learn from them.

The Wallflower

Who they are: This is your quietest member, but do not mistake quiet for a lack of care. These people work faithfully and happily in the background. People know them, but you do not hear much about them or from them. They prefer to serve without attention.

Why they need to hear from you: They do not seek the spotlight, but everyone needs to be noticed now and then. This person can easily go unseen. They need to know their work is valued and that the care team is there for them too.

Why you need to hear from them: Quiet people are often great listeners, deep thinkers, and sharp observers. If you give them time to open up, you will likely hear insights you had missed.

How to connect: Invite them to a quiet chat and thank them for their work. If they shy away from attention, take the pressure off. Catch them after the service for a short word, or send a note. Do not worry about getting the words right. In studies at the University of Chicago, people who wrote thank-you letters underestimated how positive the recipients would feel. The warmth mattered more than the wording.

The Visitor

Who they are: This is the person people talk about most on our list. Often called a guest, this is your newest visitor (and you may have a few). They are still finding their way around, learning the flow, and getting to know people. They have likely done some research on your church, so it may not be a culture shock. But they are still in a new place, trying to get their bearings.

Why they need to hear from you: Being new can be overwhelming. A warm welcome and a few follow-ups are crucial. They need to know you notice new people and care about their spiritual journey.

Why they are important: New people bring new perspectives and skills. Check in with them and help them put their gifts and experience to good use. This helps them settle in and find meaning in church life. New members may also become champions of your church and invite others in the future.

How to connect: Make visitors feel welcome. Send cookies, drop off a card, or invite them to coffee. As you get to know them, listen for their strengths and gifts and help them find their place in the church family. Build a visitor follow-up plan with early, planned check-ins so they find their fit. For timing and scripts, see our pastoral care follow-up ideas.

How Often Should a Pastor Check In?

There is no single rule. A simple rhythm helps:

  • People in a hard season (illness, grief, a new baby, a job loss): every week or two, until things settle.
  • Visitors: within the first week, then after their second or third visit.
  • Everyone else, including these four types: a personal contact a few times a year. Birthdays and anniversaries are natural times to call, so track member milestones where your team can see them.

You do not have to do all of it yourself. Share the list with your care team. And do not hold back because you think a call will feel strange. In 13 experiments with nearly 6,000 people, researchers found that people underestimate how much others appreciate being contacted, most of all when the contact is a surprise.

Getting to Know Your 4 Member Types

Now that you know these types, find them in your congregation. You likely have a few names in mind already. You may also have more than one of a type: a group of older members who have been there since the start, a new group of members, several social butterflies, or many quiet observers. Some people fit more than one type. Your oldest member may also be your most connected one.

To build your list, come at it from a few angles. Start with the people you know. Ask your care team who stands out to them. A well-connected member can help you fill in the gaps. Then keep the list where your team can see it, such as your church management system or a shared care tool. If your church uses Breeze, see how Notebird works with Breeze.

Time spent with these four types of people will strengthen your care and the bonds across your whole church. Each one sees the church from a different seat, and each one will help you care for the rest.

Common questions

Who should a pastor check in with regularly?
Start with four kinds of people who are easy to miss: your longest-serving members, the well-connected people who know everyone, the quiet helpers who work in the background, and first-time visitors. Add anyone in a hard season, such as illness, grief, or a new baby.
How often should a pastor check in with church members?
There is no single rule. A good goal is that every member hears from someone at the church at least a few times a year, and people in a hard season hear every week or two. Share the work with a care team so the pastor does not carry it alone.
How do you check in on someone at church without it feeling awkward?
Keep it short and specific. Say why you thought of them, ask one open question, and listen. A quick word after the service, a text, or a short call all work. People usually value the contact more than we expect.
How should a church follow up with first-time visitors?
Reach out within the first week with a short, warm note or call. Do not push. Invite them to one next step, such as coffee or a small group. Listen for their gifts, and check in again after their second or third visit.

Notebird is easy-to-use, dedicated pastoral care software that helps teams make sure no one falls through the cracks. Learn more about Notebird.

Free trial. Immediate peace of mind.
Start for Free Now →

Still have questions?
Contact UsSee All Features