
2 Things You Should Never Do to the Pastor Coming Behind You
When a pastor or care leader leaves, hand over the care, not just the keys. A handoff checklist, how to share private notes, and 2 things never to do.
By Thomas Griffin, Owner and CEO
Published · Updated
When a pastor or care leader leaves, hand over the care, not just the keys. Leave a written list of everyone in active care, with a short history and next step for each, plus key dates and open follow-ups. And never do two things: make promises for your successor, or leave them with no care history.
Every pastor leaves someday. Lifeway Research found that the median pastor stays eight years at one church. Of the churches that had a pastor 10 years ago, only 44% still have the same one. So most churches will go through a transition in the next decade, and many will go through more than one.
Like any traveler, a pastor leaves a mark. The best of them leave a place better than they found it. This guide is for outgoing pastors, and also for the elders, deacons, and care team leaders who stay behind and carry the care in between.
The 2 Things You Should Never Do to Your Successor
1. Do Not Make Promises for Your Successor
As you plan your exit, do not make promises on behalf of the next pastor. "The new pastor will keep the Wednesday study." "Of course the new pastor will visit you every week." Each pastor brings their own calling, gifts, and way of caring for people. Promises made for them can make it hard for them to be themselves and to connect with the church.
This also covers your own future role. The Lewis Center for Church Leadership at Wesley Theological Seminary tells departing pastors to "be clear that you will not be returning for pastoral roles". If a family asks you to do a funeral after you leave, the answer belongs to the new pastor, not to you.
So before your last Sunday, make a list of every wedding, funeral, or baptism you agreed to do. The Episcopal Diocese of Ohio's clergy leave-taking checklist asks departing clergy to clarify these commitments and make sure lay leaders "know alternate plans are in place." Then tell each family who will be there for them.
2. Do Not Leave Your Successor Without Care History
Leaving a new pastor with no care notes is like dropping them in the woods with no map. They will find their way in time. But some people will get hurt while they do.
Care history is lost in quiet ways. We have heard from churches that tracked care in a Word document and deleted each entry when a need was resolved. Others listed hospital patients on a whiteboard and erased each name when the person went home. Both work for the week. But the team is erasing its own care history, one name at a time.
Then the pastor leaves. The new pastor visits a widow and does not know her husband died last year. A man who has been sober for five years gets no word on his anniversary. A family that just lost a baby gets a cheerful "How are you?" in the lobby. None of this is the new pastor's fault. The history was simply not there.
What Is Care History, and Why Does It Matter?
Care history is the record of how the church has cared for a person over time: visits, calls, prayer requests, losses, and milestones. It is not data for its own sake. It is the story that lets the next person care well. It does three things:
- It makes care personal. When you know a person's past struggles and joys, you can ask the right question and avoid the wrong one.
- It keeps care going. A long illness, a hard divorce, or a slow grief can last longer than one pastor's time. History lets the next caregiver pick up where the last one stopped.
- It builds a legacy of care. The care your church gives today becomes the base for the next pastor, the next care team, and the next generation of the church.
What to Hand Over When a Pastor Leaves: A Checklist
The Lewis Center advises departing pastors to "prepare essential lists for your successor" and to "not take church records with you." The Diocese of Ohio asks clergy to "leave clear, confidential notes on pastoral concerns (homebound, bereaved, pending funerals) for the next clergy person." Here is what that looks like in practice.
People in active care
- Everyone in the hospital, in rehab, or facing surgery, with dates and the next step.
- Homebound members and people in care facilities, with how often they get a visit and from whom. Our homebound ministry guide can help set a schedule.
- Families grieving a death in the last 12 months, with the date of the death.
- People in crisis: job loss, divorce, addiction recovery, or serious illness. Give a short summary, not the full story.
Dates to remember
- Death dates for the bereaved, so the first anniversary does not pass in silence.
- Birthdays and wedding anniversaries of older members.
- Baptisms, confirmations, sobriety dates, and other milestones you tracked. See how churches track member milestones.
Open work
- Every open follow-up, each with a new owner and a due date.
- Every wedding, funeral, or baptism you promised, with who will do it now.
- Pre-planned funeral wishes and where they are kept.
People and access
- The names of the care team, deacons, and volunteers, and who each one visits.
- A short note on how care works here: who hears about hospital admissions first, and how.
- Logins and passwords for every church system, handed to a lay leader.
- Your care notes moved out of your personal email, phone, and drive and into a place the church owns.
Give the list to your successor if they are already called. If not, give it to one or two trusted lay leaders who will carry care in the gap.
How to Hand Over Private Notes Safely
Some care notes are deeply private: a confession, a marriage in trouble, a mental health crisis. Two rules help.
Pass on what the next pastor needs, not everything you know. "Has struggled with depression. Responds well to a short call. Do not raise it in public." is enough. The details can stay between the person and God.
Hand it to the right person. Give private notes to the next pastor alone, not to the whole board or care team. In a shared care tool, mark sensitive notes as private so volunteers see only what they need. If you are not sure what to pass on, ask your bishop, district office, or denomination for its guidance.
Do not delete accounts too soon. In any shared system, end the departing pastor's access, but check first that their notes will stay. In Notebird, archive the departing user instead of deleting them. Archiving ends their access, unassigns their open tasks, and keeps their care history visible. Reassign those tasks to someone new the same day.
When the One Who Leaves Is a Youth Pastor or Care Leader
Transitions are not only about the senior pastor. When a youth pastor leaves, students lose the adult who knew their story. We wrote a full guide on why students fall through the cracks when a youth pastor leaves.
The same is true when a deacon, care team leader, or long-time volunteer steps down. Use the checklist above for them too. The list may be shorter, but the people on it matter just as much.
Help Your Successor Start Well
A good traveler leaves a place better than they found it. Three habits help the next pastor start well.
1. Talk Openly With Your Successor
Treat the transition as a conversation, not a one-way exit. Share what you have learned, and ask about their hopes for the church. The new pastor learns how the church really works, and you can pass the baton with peace.
2. Introduce Your Successor to the People Who Need Them Most
If your time overlaps, take your successor on a few visits: the homebound, the grieving, and the long-time members who hold the church's memory. A warm introduction lets trust begin before you leave. If your time does not overlap, write a short letter of introduction for the people in active care.
3. Support Your Successor, Not the Congregation
After you leave, stay available to your successor for questions. But step back from the people. The Diocese of Ohio asks departing clergy to "not remain involved in parish life, decision-making, or pastoral care." This is hard, because you love these people. But your step back is what lets them bond with their new pastor.
If You Are the Pastor Arriving
Maybe nobody handed you a list. Start one. Ask the church secretary, the deacons, and the care team three questions: Who is sick or homebound? Who lost someone this year? Who has drifted away? Visit those people first. Our list of pastoral care questions to ask can help you learn each person's story fast.
Then build the record your own successor will need. If your church still keeps its care in a sheet or a notebook, see why spreadsheets break for care teams. The best gift you can give the next pastor is a history that does not leave with you.


